New School Model May Satisfy Parents In Rural Areas

Robert Kirwan, B.A. (Math), M.A. (Education)
Independent Education & Career Planning Agent

                Parents of a public elementary school in Warren are facing a serious problem with respect to the continuing education of their young children. The problem is that their English Language public school is too small to remain open. It only has 16 students and this is clearly not enough to provide an adequate instructional program for students. The Rainbow District School Board wants to close the school in Warren and bus the children to a larger school in nearby Markstay.
 
                Many parents are concerned that some students in rural regions already travel 40 minutes on a bus and will have to be on the bus another 40 minutes to get to Markstay. This means that primary school children will be on the bus for as long as 80 minutes in the morning and another 80 minutes in the afternoon, just to get back and forth to school. They may also have to transfer to different busses to complete the trip. That is an unacceptable situation for any young primary or junior grade children.
 
                A solution seems to be available, but it may result in the creation of a whole new type of “school model” that is inevitable if we are to solve problems in the future that are similar in nature to that being experienced in Warren.
 
                It would appear as if one school that provided instruction to all students in English and/or French would solve the problem. In other words, all students from the Warren area would all attend one school where the elementary school curriculum would be taught to them in either English or French, regardless of religion or school board affiliation. Students who wished to be provided instruction in English would be taught in English classes which would be a mix of public and Catholic students. Likewise for those wishing instruction in the French language. Split grades in this case would mean Public/Catholic or English/French and would result in teachers providing grouping within their classrooms accordingly.
 
                The Rainbow District School Board is experiencing the same problem with another school in the Walden area. R.H. Murray Public School in Whitefish, with an enrolment of about 100 students is being considered for closure while the students would be bussed to a new, larger elementary school to be built in Lively. Some of the students would be facing bus rides in excess of one hour under the move. Parents there are also upset and are doing everything possible to keep their school open.
 
REFLECTION:
 
                This may be more of a Northern or small rural school problem, but it is a solution that may be forced upon school boards unless they find a way of cooperating with each other. Parents are not going to accept bus rides of an hour or more for their young children – nor should they be expected to. Especially not when there are perfectly good buildings with space available within their local community. For these parents, the proximity of the school is more important than any school system affiliation. In other words, at this point they are not worried about whether their children attend a public or catholic system, nor are some of them worried about the English or French. They want a quality education for their children without having to subject them to up to three hours on a bus.
 
                Some sort of compromise should be considered by the Ministry of Education and the school boards for these types of situations. It should be possible to come up with a school model that would allow for the combining of all four school board systems under one roof. The funding model can be structured so that none of the existing four school boards need pay any extra money for keeping the school open and when it comes to administration and additional funding, such schools can be treated as separate entities by the province. A cooperative approach could be developed by the four school boards to accommodate the needs of the children and parents until students are ready to be bussed to larger, distant schools for the higher intermediate and secondary school grades.
 
                A solution along this line would allow parents living in areas served by Warren schools and those served by R.H. Murray in Walden, to keep their children closer to home during the important six to eight years of education from JK to Grade 6. Quality of education does not just mean what goes on inside the walls of a school building. It includes the traveling to get to the school and in most parent’s opinion, if you have to spend over 40 minutes on a bus; you have already diminished any quality of education you may receive in the classroom.
 

 
The Learning Clinic is The Private Practice of
Robert Kirwan, B.A. (Math), M.A. (Education), OCT
4456 Noel Crescent, Val Therese, ON P3P 1S8
Phone: (705) 969-7215    Email:    rkirwan@thelearningclinic.ca

Copyright © 2010 All Rights Reserved by
Infocom Canada Business Consultants Inc.